Music News

Are You a Vinyl Poser? Or Would You Rather Be Known as a Collector?

It’s Record Store Day Eve. Vinyl nerds won’t be able to sleep tonight because of visions of limited-edition records dancing in their heads. Indie record stores across the world are preparing for the onslaught of vinyl-hunting hordes. (I have an event tomorrow in Toronto at a place that actually makes vinyl. Go here to RSVP. Free food and drink!)

These are heady days for vinyl. Sales have increased by double digits year over year since 2008. Here in Canada, we’re pacing 25% ahead of last year. Pressing plants can’t keep up with demand. Labels love the fat margins, something that also allows artists to make more money off vinyl sales than from any other format. Things haven’t been this good sometime in the late 80s. It’s all unicorns and chocolate, right?

My all these measures, yes. But how many people actually listen to the vinyl they buy? The answer: a little over half.

A new survey by the BBC says that 41% of those surveyed don’t actually play their new purchases. Another 7% buy vinyl even though they don’t have a turntable.

Does this make these people vinyl posers? Your first reaction might be “Yes! Absolutely!” But maybe there something else at work here: the human need to collect something.

It’s all fine to say “I have 2.3 terabytes of music on my computer!” That’s cool. But there’s something to be said for collecting music in its physical form so that it can be displayed for all to see. This takes us back to the days when your love for music was demonstrated by the number of linear feet of shelf space devoted to records, CDs and tapes. Obviously, a substantial number of people are collecting vinyl just for the sake of collecting it. To them, vinyl is like hockey cards, Beanie Babies and charms for a bracelet.

If that’s you, good on ya. We all need a hobby, right?

Canadian Record Store Day locations.


Alan Cross

is an internationally known broadcaster, interviewer, writer, consultant, blogger and speaker. In his 40+ years in the music business, Alan has interviewed the biggest names in rock, from David Bowie and U2 to Pearl Jam and the Foo Fighters. He’s also known as a musicologist and documentarian through programs like The Ongoing History of New Music.

Alan Cross has 38162 posts and counting. See all posts by Alan Cross

One thought on “Are You a Vinyl Poser? Or Would You Rather Be Known as a Collector?

  • I consider myself a collector in the sense that I have a need to acquire more records, especially limited releases (RSD, srcvinyl and Newbury coloured reissues), but I play all of them. I don’t go after records for their collectibility, however, just their uniqueness to me.


Let us know what you think!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.